Why I Spent $225k on a Pixelated Cartoon Image of a Cowboy Wearing a VR Headset

One NBA Top Shot collector's journey to the center of the metaverse

Origins

Disgust.

That was the look on my face the night of March 7th. The punk coming my way from Pranksy's "raffle" of 150 dev punks, had just arrived. Punk #447. The dreaded stringy hair.

I had spent enough time lurking in the Punks discord. I knew stringy hair was the one trait to avoid. Fate had other ideas.

Having only paid 6 ETH for the raffle ticket a few weeks prior, I couldn't be too upset. The punk floor was now close to 20 ETH.

I listed it the next day at 33 ETH. Raffle tickets had peaked near there and I would've been comfortable with it selling.

Christie's

Fast forward. One month to the day. April 8th.

The Christie's announcement.

Punks were in a gradual downswing at that point. However, with that piece of major news, the floor rose from ~15 ETH to ~20 ETH.

I delisted #447. By that time, in about 1 month, I had grown to understand the value of owning a punk.

Punk Utility

Even with my lowly stringy hair, the utility of ownership had become obvious:

Twitter Engagement

Perhaps not by coincidence, I started tweeting in earnest the beginning of March. Shortly after swapping my avatar to #447.

My tweets are 80% Top Shot. The other 20% touch on areas that intersect with Top Shot: sports, collectibles, crypto/NFTs, technology, and business.

They seem to be resonating:

Top Shot already has somewhere north of 250k users. Interests range from disgruntled naysayers, to casual observers, to serious power users. A large number of people, myself included, spend serious amounts of time deeply enthralled with Top Shot every single day.

TSF @topshotfund

Never thought I'd say this, but I think I could write a book... about Top Shot Half my followers could too. Fascinating product really 📚

Is the Twitter “success” all because of the punk avatar? Of course not, but it damn sure helped accelerate my reach and credibility.

TSF @topshotfund

A floor punk is better than no punk at all 🧠

Community Access

There are some very accomplished punk owners. If you do your research, it's quite obvious. Impressive guys and gals across a variety of fields. Many with access to extensive networks and knowledge bases all over the world.

Does it grant you access to anyone's speed dial?

No. Not even close.

Does it lower the friction normally associated with connecting to strangers on the internet?

Absolutely.

Peruggia @peruggia_v

@topshotfund @hi_sighduck @kevinrose I had been thinking about this concept for a while but it was actually your tweet as well as the 5att smile selling to relative newcomers that inspired my tweetstorm. Most of the new money in punks seems to be buying as aesthetic of punks as possible

TSF @topshotfund

Had the top purchase of the day for all of 21 minutes. Punks ded? https://t.co/dTAHjWcyzK

Deal Flow

So far the best deal flow I've received is one of the many alt-punk projects shilling their own bags. Not much to write home about.

Will that change if my thesis on punk ownership holds true? Undoubtedly. While punks are still early in establishing themselves as a signal of credibility, behold the scale of what’s already going down:

Beanie.eth @beaniemaxi

A DAO was literally established a couple hours ago in a Twitter thread. It already has commitments of several million dollars from some of the biggest players in the space. Watching the logistics discussion play out in real time in Discord. Can a group of anons win at Christie’s?

4156 @punk4156

We have started a Discord to discuss bidding on the Christie's alien as a DAO. If you are a) thoughtful and level headed and b) interested in contributing a minimum of 100ETH, please DM.

There will be a CryptoPunks mafia full of anons one day:

balajis.com @balajis

I think the long term answer here is the pseudonymous economy. With remote work and crypto and (soon) AI avatars, no coworker needs to know anything about you — your accent, location, nationality, etc — beyond the fact that you can do your work.

marknagelberg.comNotes on The Pseudonymous Economy – Balaji SrinivasanOverview: [[Balaji Srinivasan]] looks at [[pseudonymity]], why have a pseudonymous economy, how might it work, and how could we build it.[[pseudonymity]] is not [[anonymity]]. pseudonymity is not g…

Let Me Upgrade You

I had come to the conclusion that I wanted to upgrade my punk. I evaluated my options with the following considerations:

Aesthetics & Scarcity

It's hard to say whether I'm drawn to certain traits based entirely on aesthetics. Or if a given trait's scarcity influences my opinion of its aesthetic. I'm sure the answer is some combination of the two.

Either way, I was now on the hunt for punks with the following traits:

• Top Hat (115)

• Wild White Hair (136)

• Cowboy Hat (142)

• Smile (238)

• Hoodie (259)

• 3D Glasses (286)

• Luxurious Beard (286)

• Pipe (317)

• VR (332)

• Headband (406)

• Shadow Beard (526)

• Big Shades (535)

Punk #5974 quickly caught my eye, but 82.5 ETH is nothing to scoff at.

For the analytics nerds: Detailed data on Punk rarities.

Market Conditions

Punks are at their absolute all time high. Within the past year, this very punk has sold twice for under 2.4 ETH:

It's entirely plausible (but unlikely IMO) that the Christie's auction serves as one big "buy the rumor, sell the news" OG dump fest. We've all seen how Beeple prices have fared post-Christie's.

Good news: Beeple hasn’t shaped the entire generative and digital art space in the manner that Matt and John from Larva Labs have.

Comps

I was able to find solace in the recent sales history. Punk #4780, one of the only 2 other Cowboy Hat/VRs in existence, sold for 75.5 ETH just a couple weeks ago.

In the past month alone, this account has spent 1,998 ETH (~$5.5M) on punks. If I was overpaying, at least I was in good company:

Note: It's important for me to recognize that, relative to OGs, I'm at far too large an information and capital disadvantage, to ever risk trying to flip punks. I am buying to hold. The goal is to be equally prepared for it to go to nothing, as I am to accept an offer at the right price.

Narrative Potential

Punk #5974 is quite memeable.

It pays homage to the Old West. Yet it also comes with a built in VR portal to the burgeoning metaverse.

It’s a charming juxtaposition. Culture tends to agree:

• #1 on the Billboard charts in 1974

• The song of the century so far

• One of the biggest film franchises in history

• Wildly popular HBO series

• One of nine Alien CryptoPunks

Hence my new Yat: 🤠🚀🦄

For these reasons, on top of an unhealthy dose of FOMO, I listed #447 for sale 1 ETH below the floor. It sold in less than 10 min, allowing me to anxiously finalize the purchase of #5974.

To cap things off, I used this neat tool to give my new punk a custom background color. Mine = Lakers gold to match LeBron’s jersey from the famed Kobe tribute dunk.

Beyond Punks

You have to be living under a rock to not have noticed the recent bevy of punk-centric, strategic brand campaigns:

• @punk4156 already has his own holiday, which included a massive exhibition and auction on 4/20 throughout the metaverse.

• @beaniemaxi and the @thepixelvault team brought on Marvel and DC comic Chris Wahl to help produce The Punks comic. Early renditions look amazing.

• Justin Aversano is leading an effort at his non-profit, SaveArtSpace, to transform advertisements into public PUNK art! As curated by @gmoneyNFT. Seen all over Miami recently and soon to be NYC and London as well.

• @gmoneyNFT also called for an ape meme contest. Now the winner gets to rent a Zombie punk for two weeks through a new project cryptopunk.rent.

Each of these projects are incredible additions to the punks community. A true 1+1=3 phenomena. Intrinsic value accrues to owners of the core asset, while also generating net new, creative and economic opportunities for others.

SOLD!

5 ETH for Concept Art

I present to you my plans to buy 5 ETH worth of punk #5974 concept NFTs over the course of the next month:

TSF @topshotfund

I will spend 5 ETH (~$13k USD) on original punk #5964 concept art over the next 30 days Please share with any and all artists who might be interested 🙏🏻 #SpaceCowboy 🤠

Doing this as a bit of an experiment, as well as a small way to give back. Do me a favor and share this with anyone you know who might be interested :)

Excited to see what people come up with!

Conclusion

Is it obvious that Punk kool-aid exists and that I've had a healthy serving?

Yes.

HEEEEEEEEEE Ⓜ️ @HEEEEEEEEEEE_

@topshotfund @cryptosaurus3 @NateAlexNFT "What dumb crypto thing are you into now?" "Oh, I joined a cult."

Does that necessarily mean the kool-aid is bad for you?

No. Not at all.

Scalynelson @cryptosaurus3

@topshotfund @HEEEEEEEEEEE_ @NateAlexNFT Cults are fine.

It goes without saying that nothing I've shared here should be considered financial advice. This is for informational purposes only and hopefully I delivered on that front. If you're ever considering buying a punk and have any questions, feel free to holler at me on Twitter @topshotfund.

These are 100% my own, unvarnished thoughts, and are subject to change on a moment's notice based on new information. Open to any and all critiques, just be civil!

Thanks to everyone on Twitter for your inspiration from afar. Too many of you to name, but Deeze curates the best NFT list there is.

This could be my first and only ever Substack. Zero promises, but in the event I write more and you'd like to be notified, please subscribe: